# QA Summary

**Project:** qaagent-functional-pm-qa-ui-create-test
**Run ID:** qa-20260523-213013
**Environment:** Production (qa.winds-os.com)
**Browser/Viewport:** Desktop (1366x900) + Mobile (390x844 headless Chromium)
**Execution Date:** 2026-05-23T22:00:00Z

## Scope
UI create-run smoke test — verify that a user can submit a QA run from the web form and see it appear in history with Report and Log links.

## Source Requirement Document
/var/lib/qaagent/uploads/qa-20260523-213013/qaagent-functional-pm-requirements.md

## Summary Counts

| Metric | Count |
|--------|-------|
| Requirements extracted | 1 |
| Requirements covered | 1 / 1 |
| Test cases created | 8 |
| Test cases executed | 8 |
| Passed | 5 |
| Failed | 1 |
| Blocked | 2 |
| Not tested | 0 |
| Pass rate | 62.5% |
| Open defects | 1 (Critical) |

## Recommendation: **NO-GO**

**Rationale:** One Critical defect (DEF-001) was found: the run worker is not processing newly submitted runs. The user can log in, fill in the form, and submit — the run appears in history — but it never progresses beyond "queued" status, and Report/Logs links never materialize. This breaks the end-to-end create-run flow. The product should not ship with this defect.

## Defects

| ID | Severity | Description | Status |
|----|----------|-------------|--------|
| DEF-001 | Critical | New runs stay queued; Report/Logs links never appear | Open |

## What Worked
- Login page is clean and understandable.
- Invalid password shows a clear, user-friendly error message.
- Authenticated dashboard renders correctly with all expected sections.
- Required-field validation prevents empty form submission.
- Form submission successfully creates a new row in the history table.
- Mobile viewport is usable (form + history accessible, horizontal scroll for table).

## What Did Not Work
- The run processing worker is not picking up queued runs.
- Report and Logs links are not generated for new runs.

## Product Observations (non-blocking)
- Native browser validation tooltips (TC-003) work but are not always ideal for non-technical users — inline helper text next to required fields would be friendlier.
- On mobile, the history table requires horizontal scrolling; a card-based layout for narrow screens would improve usability.
- The page has no favicon (404 on /favicon.ico).

## Limitations
- Only one browser engine tested (Chromium headless).
- Only desktop and one mobile viewport size tested.
- No accessibility audit performed.
- No performance/load testing performed.
- TC-006 and TC-007 (Report/Logs page verification) could not be executed because the Report/Logs links never appeared (blocked by DEF-001).

## Sign-off

This QA run covers the create-run smoke flow. The login, form, and history-display portions of the flow are functional. However, the run-processing backend is broken, preventing full end-to-end verification. **No-go** until the worker is fixed and Report/Logs links are confirmed working.